BFGoodrich vs Goodyear Tires: A Comparative Review

Share This Post

BFGoodrich and Goodyear share a lot in common. Both were born in Akron, Ohio, famously dubbed the ‘Rubber Capital of the World’. Initially, they focused on making bicycle tires until the dawn of the 20th century.

These companies are giants in the world of automotive tires. As of now, you can spot Goodyear tires in over 150 countries worldwide. Meanwhile, BFG has impressively churned out over 500 million tires from a single factory in Alabama alone.

Their tire offerings are quite alike as well. BFG and Goodyear provide a variety of tires, featuring different tread designs and patterns for all seasons, performance, off-road, and winter driving. These tires are suitable for cars, trucks, SUVs, crossovers, and sports cars.

However, any driver who has ever switched from BFG to Goodyear tires, or the other way around, will tell you there are noticeable differences between the two brands’ tires. To give you a clearer picture, let’s dive into a detailed comparison between BFGoodrich and Goodyear tires.

BFGoodrich History

Not many people are aware that BFGoodrich was around decades before Goodyear even came into the picture. This company, one of the pioneering tire manufacturers globally, first opened its doors in 1870 in Akron, Ohio. This launch date positions BFGoodrich as 19 years older than Michelin and holding a 2-year lead over Continental.

Despite the significant success and profits BFGoodrich has seen from selling tires, it might come as a surprise to learn that the company didn’t start producing tires until 1900. Indeed, it was only with the dawn of the 20th century that BFGoodrich ventured into the burgeoning global tire market.

What BFGoodrich may have lost in time, it certainly compensated for in market share. Within just three decades of initiating its tire production, BFGoodrich secured a monumental contract: the company was chosen to supply tires for the Ford Model A. This vehicle is an iconic one, selling over 4.2 million units during the five years it was produced.

The years that followed were filled with numerous achievements for BFGoodrich. Among these was the production of the first tubeless tire for American cars in 1947. Moreover, BFGoodrich is distinguished by two notable firsts: it’s credited with creating the world’s first all-terrain tire in 1976, and in 2002, it introduced the first 24-inch 4×4 tire. These innovations underline the United States’ capability to lead in tire manufacturing technology.

BFGoodrich Tire Collections

BFGoodrich boasts six unique tire families: g-Force, Radial, All-Terrain, Mud-Terrain, Winter, and Commercial. Let’s take a closer look at each category.

g-Force

The g-Force collection is all about performance, offering tires designed for high-speed stability and top-notch steering response. Whether it’s dry or wet conditions, these tires aim to maintain excellent traction and cornering abilities.

If you’re on the hunt for a tire that embodies these qualities, the g-Force Sport Comp-2 is a standout choice. This high-performance, all-season tire doesn’t just excel in the basics; thanks to BFG’s Equal Tension Containment (ETEC) System, it also promises longevity on the road.

Radial

Did you know BFGoodrich played a crucial role in refining the technology behind today’s radial tires? Although Michelin and Bridgestone were pioneers, BFG’s contributions have significantly advanced radial tire technology.

For a firsthand experience of BFG’s innovative radial tire technology, the BFG Radial T/A Terrain is a perfect example. This tire is engineered for year-round enhanced traction, with special sidewall stabilizers to ensure it remains sturdy without compromising handling.

All-Terrain

BFG’s all-terrain tires are noteworthy for their performance, particularly:

  • BFG T/A KO: A legendary all-terrain tire from BFG’s lineup, the T/A KO has been succeeded by the T/A KO2 but continues to be a favorite among off-road enthusiasts.
  • BFG T/A KO2: The KO2 improves upon its predecessor with 15% longer tread life on roads and 20% greater resistance against sidewall damage, showcasing BFG’s commitment to innovation.

Mud-Terrain

BFG’s mud-terrain tires are designed with wider gaps between tread blocks for self-cleaning, aggressive tread patterns for superior mud and soft soil traction, and reinforced blocks for durability. Their robust sidewall design further enhances protection against punctures and damage, making them a top choice in the market.

Winter

Currently, BFG’s winter tire lineup features the T/A KSI. This model is available in 57 sizes, ranging from 14 to 20 inches, and is marked with the Three Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) and Mud + Snow (M+S) symbols. It’s built to perform reliably in both icy conditions and heavy snow.

Commercial

BFGoodrich’s commercial tire family is tailored to meet the demands of professional driving, offering durability, reliability, and performance for commercial vehicles. Whether for long hauls or rigorous daily tasks, BFG’s commercial tires are engineered to keep businesses moving forward.

Goodyear Tires History

The Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company was born in 1898 in Akron, Ohio. Its creator, Frank A. Seiberling, took a leap of faith with a $3,500 loan to breathe life into Goodyear, picking up the pieces from the defunct Goodyear India Rubber Company.

In its early days, Goodyear focused on making tires for bicycles and carriages. But it wasn’t long before innovation struck. Four years in, they rolled out the Non-Skid, their pioneering automobile tire. This tire featured a unique tread design that was a game-changer, providing much better grip on soggy roads and setting a standard for future car tires.

Yet, the real breakthrough came with the All-Weather Tread. This all-season marvel was a hit for its unmatched grip, regardless of the weather. When World War I erupted, Goodyear’s expertise was called upon, securing a deal to supply tires for military vehicles and aircraft used by the allied forces.

Goodyear didn’t stop there. Their track record of innovation is marked by the Blue Streak, a tire designed for the speed demons of racing, and the introduction of the world’s first tubeless tire. Today, Goodyear’s legacy continues, crafting tires for vehicles as common as the family car and as specialized as farm machinery.

Goodyear Tire Families

Goodyear’s lineup is a diverse family of ten tire groups. These groups are the Goodyear Assurance, Eagle, Ultra Grip, Winter Command, Wrangler, Efficient Grip, Excellence, Fierce, Fortera, and Integrity. Let’s dive into the specifics of each Goodyear tire family.

Goodyear Assurance

The Assurance group from Goodyear is filled with tires designed for all seasons and all types of weather. Standouts in the all-season category include the Assurance Fuel Max, Assurance Outlast, and Assurance Max Life. Then there’s the Assurance WeatherReady, a top contender in the all-weather tire category.

What these tires share are impressive qualities like excellent handling, a smooth drive, and great fuel efficiency. Except for the Assurance WeatherReady, they also offer treadwear warranties that rival those of Michelin’s AS tires.

Goodyear Eagle

The Eagle family is where Goodyear houses its performance and high-performance tires. These tires are built for those who prioritize exceptional grip and cornering over comfort and quiet rides. They excel in straight-line tracking, responsive steering, and stability at high speeds.

Looking for evidence? The Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 is a standout ultra-high-performance tire known for its incredibly short braking distances on wet surfaces. For those seeking even more sporty performance, the Eagle F1 SportCar 3 is a must-consider.

Goodyear Ultra Grip

Designed for the toughest weather conditions, the Ultra Grip tires remain flexible even in the coldest temperatures, thanks to their super-flexible tread compound. Their design, which includes biting edges and a water evacuation system, also contributes to their effectiveness.

Within the Ultra Grip line, you’ll find studless and studdable winter tires. If you’re not dealing with extreme snow, the studless options are sufficient. However, while studdable tires can offer better traction in winter, they may harm the roads.

Goodyear Winter Command

True to its name, the Winter Command series promises safe travel over icy and snowy surfaces.

All Winter Command tires can be studded, setting them apart from the Ultra Grip series. This feature, however, might not be suitable if your local regulations restrict the use of studded tires on public roads.

Goodyear Wrangler

For the off-road adventurers, the Wrangler series is perfect. It includes all-terrain, mud-terrain, and rugged terrain tires, ensuring reliability across mud, snow, slush, gravel, and rocky terrains.

To give you a taste, consider the Trail Runner AT and the All-Terrain Adventure. Both are well-equipped to navigate tough paths and trails confidently.

Goodyear Efficient Grip and Excellence

Grouping these two families together makes sense due to their shared focus on balancing performance with refinement. For those seeking solid road handling without compromising on comfort, these tire families are worth exploring.

Goodyear Fierce

Despite what you might think, the Wrangler tires aren’t Goodyear’s sole offering for off-road enthusiasts.

The Fierce family also stands ready to tackle mud, slush, gravel, and snow. However, it falls short when it comes to rock crawling.

Goodyear Fortera

For those who rarely venture off paved roads, the Fortera series offers an ideal solution. This lineup, consisting of SL (sporty) and HL (highway) tires, aims to maximize comfort and minimize noise—though the SL variants might be a bit louder than expected.

Goodyear Integrity

In its mission to capture a portion of the budget tire market, Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company has acquired several smaller brands. The Integrity series represents another step towards providing affordable options without sacrificing quality. It’s a testament to Goodyear’s commitment to serve drivers looking for budget-friendly yet reliable tires.

BFGoodrich vs. Goodyear Tires: What Sets Them Apart

Performance

When it comes to high-performing tires for various driving and weather conditions, both BFGoodrich and Goodyear are top choices. But, if you’re after a tire that brings sporty handling and a responsive feel to your driving, BFGoodrich is often the go-to choice. This preference isn’t just ours; car enthusiasts and motorsport fans echo this sentiment.

Availability of Options

While Goodyear boasts ten tire families compared to BFGoodrich’s six, don’t be fooled into thinking BFGoodrich falls short in variety. A closer look reveals that both brands cover every possible tire type you might need. So, despite a smaller lineup, BFGoodrich matches Goodyear in the breadth of options available.

Price & Warranty

Typically, BFGoodrich tires come with a higher price tag than Goodyear’s offerings. This stems from BFGoodrich’s focus on high-performance tires, which naturally cost more than the all-season tires Goodyear primarily produces. Consequently, Goodyear tires often come with more generous treadwear warranties. Additionally, Goodyear’s “Fuel Saver Limited Warranty” promises at least a 2% reduction in fuel consumption compared to its competitors, offering a bit more value.

Advantages of Goodyear Tires

  • Premier all-season touring tires
  • Extended treadwear warranties
  • Dependable options for off-roading adventures

Advantages of BFGoodrich Tires

  • Outstanding performance in high-performance categories
  • Ideal for race cars, muscle cars, and sports cars, thanks to superior steering response, cornering ability, and grip

BFGoodrich Vs Goodyear Tires: Which One to Choose?

When selecting tires for your vehicle, the decision between BFGoodrich and Goodyear tires depends on your primary driving environment. It also depends on what you value most in a tire. BFGoodrich tires shine on the racing track, where performance, grip, and speed are paramount. They are designed to withstand high-speed driving’s rigorous demands. This makes them an ideal choice for enthusiasts who crave the adrenaline rush of racing. The precision and handling offered by BFGoodrich tires ensure that drivers can navigate tracks with confidence.

On the other hand, Goodyear tires are synonymous with comfort and reliability for everyday driving. Whether you’re navigating city streets or cruising on the highway, Goodyear tires are engineered to provide a smooth and quiet ride. They are built to offer excellent traction in various conditions, from wet roads to dry pavements. This ensures safety and peace of mind during your daily commutes. Additionally, Goodyear tires often feature advanced technology that enhances durability and fuel efficiency. This makes them a practical choice for drivers who prioritize long-term value and comfort over high-speed thrills.

In essence, your choice between BFGoodrich and Goodyear tires should reflect your driving habits and preferences. If the thrill of the track is what drives you, BFGoodrich is the way to go. However, Goodyear emerges as the preferable option for those who value comfort, safety, and efficiency in their everyday journeys.

Related Posts

Picture of Lucas Liam

Lucas Liam

Hi, I'm Liam, the enthusiast behind Off Road Genius. With more than 10 years of conquering diverse terrains, my experience with Jeeps extends beyond the ordinary. I've mastered the intricate details of these off-road champions, pushing their capabilities to the limit. Through this platform, I share my profound knowledge and lessons learned from countless miles on the trail. I'm here to inspire, educate, and guide you through the thrilling world of Jeeps. So, buckle up for this adventure-filled ride!

Learn More about the best jeep accessories