Comparing Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 Vs Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

Share This Post

Are you searching for the ultimate summer performance tires? Dive into our side-by-side look at the Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 and the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S. These tires are at the forefront of their category, setting the standard for others to follow.

The Firehawk Indy 500 shines with its exceptional cornering abilities, short stopping distances on dry surfaces, and top-notch steering feedback. Michelin’s Pilot Sport 4S mirrors these strengths, standing as one of the company’s top performance tires.

Yet, despite targeting the same audience, there are notable differences between them. For instance, the Indy 500 presents a more wallet-friendly option for those seeking summer performance tires, whereas the Pilot Sport 4S might stretch your budget further than expected.

Firestone Firehawk Indy 500

The Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 is a summer performance tire that you can find in sizes from 16 to 20 inches. This variety means it fits a lot of cars, like the Volkswagen Jetta, Dodge Charger, and Volvo S60, to name a few.

I’ve had these tires on my Nissan Sentra and I’ve got to say, they’re pretty awesome when it comes to handling on dry surfaces and they stick to the road even when it’s pouring. It’s rare to find tires that keep their grip when you really push them, but the Indy 500 does just that.

What really makes you love driving with these tires is how they handle turns and give you feedback that makes you feel connected to the road. It’s the kind of tire that makes driving fun, especially when you’re zipping around corners with ease.

But what convinced me wasn’t just how it performs. It’s the price of the Firehawk Indy 500 that sealed the deal. It’s priced in the middle range, which is pretty great for a tire that performs this well without breaking the bank.

Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

Now, the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is a serious competitor, outdoing the Indy 500 in several ways.

First off, it matches the Indy 500 stride for stride with its grip on dry surfaces and traction in the rain. It also has solid aquaplaning resistance, keeping the car stable on wet roads.

It’s built tough too, with double steel belts and a reinforced sidewall to cut down on wear and tear. Plus, it comes with tread wear indicators to let you know when it’s time for a change.

Where it really beats the Indy 500 is in its durability and comfort. Michelin offers a 30,000-mile warranty on the Pilot Sport 4S, something the Indy 500 lacks. It’s also designed to be quieter, and it performs better in rainy conditions, giving it an edge over its rival.

The Main Differences

This part will guide you in choosing whether the Firehawk Indy 500 or the Pilot Sport 4S is the right choice for your vehicle.

Comparing Off-road Performance

Both tires are not meant for off-road adventures.

If you’re clued up about off-road tires, you’ll know they come with tough sidewalls, tread compounds resistant to cuts and chips, large gaps between tread blocks, and features that clean themselves to shine in rough terrains.

These characteristics allow off-road tires to navigate through mud, slush, gravel, and rocks with ease. However, they’re not the best pick for highway driving, which is the playground of both Indy 500 and Pilot Sport 4S tires.

Winner: Tie

Comparing On-road Performance

How do they stack up in dry conditions?

Given both tires are designed for summer performance, it’s expected that the Indy 500 and Pilot Sport 4S excel in dry grip and maneuverability.

The Indy 500, with its advanced silica compound, lets you push the limits, whether that’s in a street race or a relaxed drive along the coast. Its rigid shoulder blocks also mean it corners like a dream.

Meanwhile, the Pilot Sport 4S features a V-shaped tread design for outstanding dry handling, stability at high speeds, and excellent cornering traction. Its contact area grows as you speed up, ensuring control at faster velocities.

In essence, both tires shine when it comes to dry performance.

Winner: Tie

How do they fare on wet roads?

If rain is a common companion on your drives, here’s why the Pilot Sport 4S might be your best bet:

Its tread compound is enriched with elastomers to boost wet traction. This reduces the braking distance significantly, lowering the accident risk.

The Pilot Sport 4S also incorporates silica in its tread, enhancing grip on wet surfaces by keeping the rubber supple, essential for maintaining control in rainy weather.

With wide circumferential and diagonal grooves, it quickly removes water, ensuring better performance in wet conditions compared to the Indy 500, which some drivers find a bit slippery on wet roads.

Winner: Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

Are They Good in the Handling Department?

There are a few key differences between these two tires when it comes to how well they handle.

For drivers who value sharp and quick responses from their tires, the Indy 500 might just be the perfect choice. Its design, featuring a directional tread pattern for swift steering reactions and substantial shoulder blocks for enhanced grip during tight turns, stands out.

On the flip side, if smooth handling with minimal steering feedback is more your style, the Pilot Sport 4S could be the ideal match. Thanks to its broader contact area compared to its predecessor, the Pilot Super Sport, it strikes an excellent balance.

Winner: It’s a draw.

Comparing Snow Performance

Having tested both tires in various conditions, it’s clear that neither is cut out for snowy or icy roads.

Although the Pilot Sport 4S is promoted as an all-year-round tire, it lacks crucial features like aggressive sipes, a super-flexible tread compound, and a specialized tread design that are essential for optimal winter performance.

For those in search of a winter-ready tire, we’ve compiled a list of top snow tire recommendations.

Winner: It’s a draw.

Comparing Treadwear and Durability

Based on my personal use, the Indy 500 seems to wear down faster, especially under rigorous driving. The Pilot Sport 4S, however, maintains its durability and traction well, even as tread depth decreases to less-than-ideal levels.

A look at the treadwear warranties further supports this, with the Pilot Sport 4S guaranteed for up to 30,000 miles, while the Indy 500 offers no such assurance.

Winner: Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

Comparing on Comfort

For those who prioritize comfort above all, the Pilot Sport 4S is the way to go.

Its wider contact patch ensures a smoother interaction with the road, leading to less cabin vibration. This tire is designed to easily soak up road imperfections, making for a more comfortable ride compared to the Indy 500.

Additionally, Michelin’s Acoustic Technology, which is incorporated into some sizes, utilizes a special foam to reduce road noise, making your drives quieter by a significant margin.

Winner: Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

Comparing on Price

The Pilot Sport 4S comes with a higher price tag than the Indy 500.

This shouldn’t come as a surprise, considering Firestone’s position as a mid-range brand offering budget-friendly, high-performance tires. Michelin, on the other hand, is recognized globally for its premium tires, made with advanced technologies and high-quality materials, reflected in their pricing.

Winner: Firestone Firehawk Indy 500

Firestone Firehawk Indy 500: The Good and the Not-So-Good

The Good:

  • Priced for the budget-conscious — these tires won’t break the bank.
  • Excels on dry surfaces — offering dynamic handling that makes every drive thrilling.
  • Top-tier cornering abilities — grip and performance in curves are outstanding.

The Not-So-Good:

  • No promise on how long they’ll last — missing a treadwear warranty.
  • Could do better when it’s pouring — wet road grip leaves room for improvement.

Michelin Pilot Sport 4S: The Highs and Lows

The Highs:

  • Ride in comfort — these tires are designed for a smooth journey.
  • They’ve got your back for 30,000 miles — with a treadwear warranty that reassures.
  • A champ in rainy conditions — excellent at resisting water and keeping grip.

The Lows:

  • Wishing for quicker reactions — could be a tad more responsive.
  • Your wallet will feel it — premium quality comes at a premium price.

Choosing the Right Tire for Your Ride

Lean towards the Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 if you’re all about:

  • Getting more bang for your buck — performance doesn’t always have to be pricey.
  • Mastering dry roads — for handling and performance that shine when the sun does.
  • Steering that feels just right — exceptional response and feedback at your fingertips.

Or, go for the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S if you prioritize:

  • Comfort and control combined — enjoy smooth rides with top handling.
  • A solid treadwear promise — peace of mind for miles and miles.
  • Staying sure-footed in the rain — for grip that doesn’t quit, even when the weather turns.
Picture of Lucas Liam

Lucas Liam

Hi, I'm Liam, the enthusiast behind Off Road Genius. With more than 10 years of conquering diverse terrains, my experience with Jeeps extends beyond the ordinary. I've mastered the intricate details of these off-road champions, pushing their capabilities to the limit. Through this platform, I share my profound knowledge and lessons learned from countless miles on the trail. I'm here to inspire, educate, and guide you through the thrilling world of Jeeps. So, buckle up for this adventure-filled ride!

Learn More about the best jeep accessories