Firestone Destination AT2 vs Cooper Discoverer AT3

Share This Post

Tires are not all created equal. Some shine in stability, performance, and grip, while others stand out for lasting longer, offering more comfort, and being more efficient. The materials that makeup tires can differ greatly, even between two tires that look quite similar. When you think about the size of the tire, your choices grow even more.

Take the Firestone Destination AT2 and the Cooper Discoverer AT3, for example. They’re both all-terrain tires designed for vehicles ready to tackle any adventure. While they might look similar on paper, in reality, they’re not the same. Curious to know the differences? Keep reading to find out.

Firestone Destination AT2

Born in the USA, Firestone has been crafting tires since the 1900s dawn. From the start, the brand built a solid reputation for creating reliable and affordable tires. Firestone’s success caught the eye of the tire giant Bridgestone, leading to a merge that propelled Firestone to new heights.

The Destination AT2 tire, with its 3PMFT rating, is an all-season champ for a range of vehicles. It takes the legacy of the Destination series up a notch. Compared to its predecessor, the AT2 shines, especially in heavy snow, outperforming the AT1 with noticeable superiority.

Featuring an updated tread design, bold shoulder edges, and broader grooves, the AT2 aims for enhanced grip in the thick of snow and water. It’s built to resist aquaplaning effectively, making it a tire that digs deep and holds its ground under challenging conditions.

Cooper Discoverer AT3

Founded in Ohio, USA, in 1914, the Cooper Tire Company has been crafting well-designed, all-purpose tires for a wide variety of vehicles for over a century. By the 1960s, Cooper made its mark on the New York Stock Exchange as a publicly held entity. Fast forward to 2021, and Goodyear’s acquisition of Cooper only underscores the quality and appeal of Cooper’s tires.

The Cooper Discoverer AT3 stands out as an all-terrain tire that caters to several vehicle types. Designed with a focus on on-road performance, the AT3 model range effortlessly transitions to off-road adventures. These tires are winter-rated, ensuring smooth navigation through snowy and icy conditions.

When it comes to dry terrain, the AT3 proves itself remarkable, especially for an all-terrain tire. Dubbed a “jack of all trades,” the AT3 consistently delivers strong performance across various conditions. In the sections below, we’ll dive into the specifics and advantages of the AT3 tires.

Pros of the Firestone Destination AT2 Tire

The Firestone Destination AT2 tire stands out for its versatility and durability. It boasts a 55,000-mile treadwear warranty, guaranteeing long-lasting performance.

These tires are 3PMSF rated, indicating their ability to handle deep snow conditions with ease, ensuring top-notch snow performance while maintaining comfort on the road.

On the topic of on-road driving, the AT2 tires provide excellent grip and traction across various conditions. They are designed to be quiet and comfortable, thanks to their thicker sidewalls, enhancing the driving experience.

Aquaplaning resistance is another highlight of these tires. Firestone emphasizes this feature, which means the AT2s are engineered to effectively navigate through heavy snow, water, and slush.

With a robust design, the AT2 tires are well-equipped for nearly any terrain, including dirt roads, mud, and sand, all while being gentle on the road. This tire truly embodies the essence of a well-rounded option, but before comparing them to the Cooper Discoverer AT3s, it’s crucial to explore the Discoverer AT3s’ advantages.

What Are The Pros Of The Cooper Discoverer AT3 Tire?

The Cooper Discoverer AT3 tire series is built to deliver top-notch performance on the road, ensuring a smooth ride across various challenging terrains. These tires shine with their 3PMSF (Three-Peak Mountain Snow Flake) rating, indicating their superior capability in handling snow and ice conditions.

A standout feature of the AT3s is their impressive 65,000-mile tread life warranty. This guarantee underscores their long-lasting durability and optimal performance over time. Additionally, Cooper equips the AT3 tires with its exclusive Advanced Traction Technology and Saw Tooth Technology. These innovations are crafted to enhance grip across all conditions, particularly on snowy surfaces.

The AT3s boast a zig-zag tread design, ingeniously engineered to trap snow effectively. This unique pattern fosters a stronger grip on snow-covered roads, significantly boosting traction. In terms of handling snow and ice, the AT3s often surpass expectations, proving themselves as more than capable of both winter challenges and regular on-road driving.

Despite their all-terrain design, the AT3 tires are noted for their comfort. Thanks to a double-ply polyester casing, they excel at smoothing out imperfections on the road, offering a ride that’s comfortable compared to many all-terrain options. However, it’s worth noting they may be on the noisier side, a common trait for tires in this category.

What Are The Main Differences Between The Firestone Destination AT2 And The Cooper Discoverer AT3?

Let’s dive into a showdown between the Firestone Destination AT2 and the Cooper Discoverer AT3, comparing them across several critical aspects: treadwear, off-road and on-road capabilities, snow-driving performance, comfort, pricing, and warranty coverage.

Both tires have their merits, ensuring whichever you choose should leave you quite content. While aesthetics can also be a point of comparison, beauty really does lie in the beholder’s eyes.

Treadwear: Firestone Destination AT2 vs. Cooper Discoverer AT3

Durability is key for any tire, as even the most robust performers are worthless if they wear down too fast, particularly when they come with a hefty price tag. Fortunately, neither the Firestone Destination AT2s nor the Cooper Discoverer AT3s fall into this category. These tires are crafted to handle a variety of driving conditions with grace, thanks to each brand’s unique treadwear technology ensuring consistent and predictable wear. Both sets of tires are expected to maintain their performance well, up until the tread depth approaches the critical 2/32-inch mark.

Winner: This round ends in a tie.

Off-road Performance: Firestone Destination AT2 vs Cooper Discoverer AT3

Both the Firestone Destination AT2 and Cooper Discoverer AT3 tires can handle off-road conditions. However, neither is a true off-road tire. While the Firestone Destination AT2 tires can take on various terrains, they’re not the top choice for intense off-roading. The same goes for the Cooper Discoverer AT3. They’re capable for casual off-road adventures but might fall short in more demanding scenarios.

In direct comparison, the Firestone Destination AT2 has a slight edge for off-roading, offering a bit more versatility.

Winner: Firestone Destination AT2

On-road Performance: Firestone Destination AT2 vs Cooper Discoverer AT3

Not all tires can excel on every surface, but the Firestone Destination AT2s impress on pavement. They offer a smooth, quiet ride with excellent control, striking a fine balance between off-road capability and on-road manners.

The Cooper Discoverer AT3s also shine on paved roads and trails, providing strong performance in both environments. They may not be as quiet as the Firestone Destination AT2s, but they offer superior traction in various conditions. Both sets of tires are reliable for daily driving. If choosing between the two, the Cooper Discoverer AT3s have a slight advantage for on-road use.

Winner: Cooper Discoverer AT3

Snow-driving Performance: Firestone Destination AT2 vs Cooper Discoverer AT3

When it comes to driving in snow, you’re entering a tricky terrain where not all tires can shine. But, breathe easy—both the Firestone Destination AT2s and the Cooper Discoverer AT3s hold their ground here, as they’re 3PMSF-rated. This rating means they’re equipped to handle both light and heavy snow with ease.

Yet, in this snowy arena, the Cooper Discoverer AT3s take the lead, thanks to their zig-zag tread pattern that boosts traction in the snow. What’s more, these tires come with a special silica compound, which keeps them soft in freezing temps. The Cooper AT3s perform so well in snow, it’s almost hard to believe they’re not specially made snow tires. The Firestone AT2s also perform admirably, yet they don’t quite reach the heights of the AT3s.

Winner: Cooper Discoverer AT3

Comfort: Firestone Destination AT2 vs Cooper Discoverer AT3

Let’s clear something up first: neither of these tires are meant for extreme off-roading. That means both Firestone and Cooper designed these tires for everyday use. Choosing a clear winner in comfort is tough, as each tire excels in different aspects. The Firestone AT2s might not absorb bumps as well as the AT3s, but the AT3s tend to be noisier on the road.

Both tire options come with a relatively high sidewall, allowing for more flex over bumps. However, the Cooper Discoverer AT3s seem to edge out in noise and vibrations a bit more.

Winner: Firestone Destination AT2

Price: Firestone Destination AT2 vs Cooper Discoverer AT3

Money talks. When you’re comparing two things based on how much they cost, you’d think the one with the higher price tag might be better. But that’s not what’s happening here. Both the Firestone Destination AT2 and the Cooper Discoverer AT3 are strong competitors across many areas, making it tough to choose between them. What makes the decision even harder is their price tags are nearly the same.

At the moment, Walmart sells the Cooper Discoverer AT3 265/70/R17 for $201.99, while the Firestone Destination AT2 265/70R17 is a bit cheaper at $195.88. So, even though their prices are almost identical, we have to choose a winner for this round, and it’s the AT2.

Winner: Firestone Destination AT2

Warranty: Firestone Destination AT2 vs Cooper Discoverer AT3

The Firestone Destination AT2 steps up with a 55,000-mile tread warranty. This is a 5,000-mile improvement over the first generation, showing Firestone’s confidence in the AT2’s longevity. The Cooper Discoverer AT3, though, goes even further with a 65,000-mile tread warranty.

Winner: Cooper Discoverer AT3

Why Should I Pick Firestone AT2 Over Cooper Discoverer AT3?

  • Slightly better off-road performance: If you love adventures and often find yourself off the beaten path, the Firestone AT2 steps up the game. It’s tailored for those who crave a bit more excitement and challenge in rugged terrains.
  • Slightly more comfortable: For those long drives or daily commutes, comfort is key. The Firestone AT2 ensures a smoother ride, making every journey more enjoyable.
  • Noticeably quieter: Enjoy the sound of silence? The Firestone AT2 is engineered to reduce road noise, providing a noticeably quieter ride. This means less distraction and more relaxation while you drive.
  • Cheaper: Everyone loves a good deal. Choosing the Firestone AT2 not only offers great performance but also saves you money. It’s a win-win for your wallet and your vehicle.

Why Should I Pick Cooper Discoverer AT3 Over Firestone AT2?

  • Better in snow: When winter hits and the roads are covered in snow, the Cooper Discoverer AT3 shines. It’s designed to keep you moving safely and confidently, even in the chilliest conditions.
  • Better in wet conditions: Rainy days can be tricky on the road. The Cooper Discoverer AT3 offers superior performance in wet conditions, ensuring better grip and safety when you need it most.
  • Better in the snow: Emphasizing its prowess in cold climates, the Cooper Discoverer AT3 doubles down on its snow capabilities. It’s all about keeping you secure and steady, no matter how deep the snow gets.
  • Better warranty: Peace of mind comes standard with the Cooper Discoverer AT3. Its superior warranty coverage protects your investment, making it a smart choice for those who prioritize reliability and support.

Wrap Up

The Firestone Destination AT2 and Cooper Discoverer AT3 both excel as all-terrain tires, yet they stand apart in their offerings. Opt for the Firestone Destination AT3s if snow-covered roads are not your usual path and you’re in search of the quietest ride. The price gap between the two is quite slight, making it less of a deciding factor.

Picture of Lucas Liam

Lucas Liam

Hi, I'm Liam, the enthusiast behind Off Road Genius. With more than 10 years of conquering diverse terrains, my experience with Jeeps extends beyond the ordinary. I've mastered the intricate details of these off-road champions, pushing their capabilities to the limit. Through this platform, I share my profound knowledge and lessons learned from countless miles on the trail. I'm here to inspire, educate, and guide you through the thrilling world of Jeeps. So, buckle up for this adventure-filled ride!

Learn More about the best jeep accessories